Carroll Fife
Councilmember, District 3 on the Oakland City Council
Source: Official roster, oaklandca.gov
In the records we collect, Carroll cast 214 recorded votes, voted with the final outcome 95% of the time, attended 3 of 6 recorded meetings, and made 33 motions.
"Final outcome" compares each Yea or Nay with whether the measure passed, across 154 votes. Counts cover the records listed at the end of this page.
Where Carroll stands
On 11 recorded votes where members disagreed, Carroll was on the prevailing side 3 times and in the minority 8 times. The minority votes were most often on public safety & emergency services and infrastructure spending - roadways.
- Public Safety & Emergency ServicesYes 0, No 7
- Voted no on Subject: Memoranda Of Understanding Between The City And The Oakland Police Officers’ Association From: Human Resources Management Department.... Pass 6 to 1, Oct 6, 2026. Record
- Voted no on Subject: Estate Of Lolomania Soakai, Et Al ($17.0M). Pass 7 to 1, Sep 15, 2026. Record
- Voted no on 2) A Resolution Approving The Tentative Agreement For The Memorandum Of Understanding Between The City Of Oakland And The Oakland Police Officers’....
What they bring forward
Topics of the motions they made, grouped into descriptive policy areas by the wording of each official title.
- Public Safety & Emergency Services7 motions
- Infrastructure Spending - Roadways5 motions
- Housing & Development2 motions
- Fiscal Policy - Taxation2 motions
- Fiscal Policy - Budget Allocation2 motions
- Zoning Amendment - Land Use2 motions
- Government Operations - Appointments2 motions
- Labor & Employment
When the vote split
Unanimous votes say little about how members differ. These are the recorded votes where members disagreed, most recent first.
- Yea
- Nay
- Absent or not voting
- Abstain or present
- Oct 20, 2026Oakland * Concurrent Meeting of the Oakland Redevelopment Successor Agency and the City Council
Subject: Procurement Of Ready-Mix Concrete From: Department Of Transportation Recommendation: Adopt A Resolution: (1) Authorizing The City Administrator To Purchase Ready-Mix Concrete From CalPortland Company, CEMEX Construction Materials, And One Additional Eligible Ready-Mix Concrete Supplier, Including A New Market Entrant, On An As-Needed Basis For A Four-Year Period In An Amount Not To Exceed Four Hundred Thousand Dollars ($400,000) Per Supplier Per Year, For An Annual Aggregate Amount Not To Exceed One Million Two Hundred Thousand Dollars ($1,200,000) And A Total Four-Year Aggregate Amount Not To Exceed Four Million Eight Hundred Thousand Dollars ($4,800,000); (2) Authorizing Payment Of Unpaid Invoices Due To CalPortland Company In An Amount Not To Exceed Seventy Thousand Dollars ($70,000); (3) Waiving Further Advertising And Competitive Bidding Pursuant To Oakland Municipal Code 2.04.050(I)(2) And Authorizing Open-Market Purchases Pursuant To Oakland Municipal Code 2.04.050(J);
Adopted; Motion by Rowena Brown; seconded by Charlene Wang
Pass 5 to 1. Infrastructure Spending - Roadways.
Records used on this page
Each vote and bill above links to its own official record.